Hardscape Material Comparison Guide
Compare pavers, concrete, and asphalt to choose the best material for your outdoor project. Understand the pros, cons, costs, and durability of each option.
Material Comparison at a Glance
| Feature | Pavers | Concrete | Asphalt |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material Cost (per sq ft) | $8-$25 | $3-$8 | $2-$5 |
| Installation Cost (per sq ft) | $10-$20 | $5-$10 | $3-$7 |
| Lifespan | 25-50+ years | 20-30 years | 15-25 years |
| Maintenance Level | Low | Low | Medium-High |
| Repair Ease | Excellent (individual replacement) | Poor (patch shows) | Good (overlay possible) |
| Weather Resistance | Excellent | Good (cracks in freeze/thaw) | Fair (softens in heat) |
| DIY Installation | Moderate difficulty | Difficult (requires skill) | Professional only |
| Design Flexibility | Excellent (colors, patterns, shapes) | Good (stamps, stains) | Limited (black/gray) |
🧱
Pavers (Concrete & Natural Stone)
Individual interlocking units offering maximum design flexibility and durability
✓ Advantages
- •Longest Lifespan: 25-50+ years with minimal maintenance. Natural stone pavers can last 50-100+ years.
- •Easy Repairs: Replace individual damaged pavers without disturbing surrounding area. No visible patches.
- •Design Versatility: Hundreds of colors, textures, shapes, and patterns. Mix and match for unique designs.
- •No Cracking: Flexible joints between pavers prevent cracking from freeze-thaw cycles or ground movement.
- •Immediate Use: Walk on surface immediately after installation. No curing time required.
- •Increased Property Value: High-end appearance boosts curb appeal and resale value more than concrete or asphalt.
- •Better Drainage: Permeable options available that allow water infiltration, reducing runoff and puddling.
✗ Disadvantages
- •Higher Upfront Cost: $18-$45 per sq ft installed vs. $8-$18 for concrete or $5-$12 for asphalt.
- •Labor-Intensive Installation: More time required than pouring concrete. Proper base preparation is critical.
- •Weed Growth: Weeds can grow in joints if polymeric sand not used. Requires re-sanding every 3-5 years.
- •Edge Restraints Required: Must install proper edge restraints or pavers will spread over time.
- •Snow Removal Challenge: Plow edges can catch on pavers. Use rubber-edged plows or raised plow blade.
💡 Best Use Cases:
- • High-end residential patios and walkways
- • Driveways where aesthetics matter
- • Pool decks (non-slip surfaces)
- • Commercial plazas and courtyards
- • Areas with freeze-thaw cycles
🏗️
Poured Concrete
Monolithic surface offering cost-effectiveness and quick installation
✓ Advantages
- •Lower Initial Cost: $8-$18 per sq ft installed vs. $18-$45 for pavers. Most affordable permanent option.
- •Faster Installation: Pour and finish in 1-2 days. Cure time is 28 days but can walk after 24-48 hours.
- •Smooth Surface: Perfectly flat, smooth finish ideal for basketball courts, workshops, garage floors.
- •Decorative Options: Can be stamped, stained, or colored to mimic pavers or natural stone at lower cost.
- •Custom Shapes: Easy to pour curved or irregular shapes. Forms can create any design.
- •Low Maintenance: Seal every 2-3 years. Power wash annually. Minimal ongoing care required.
✗ Disadvantages
- •Cracks Inevitable: Will crack over time from settling, temperature changes, or freeze-thaw. Expect cracks within 5-10 years.
- •Difficult Repairs: Patches are visible and rarely match original. Often requires complete replacement.
- •Shorter Lifespan: 20-30 years vs. 25-50+ for pavers. Replacement costs offset initial savings.
- •Salt Damage: De-icing salts cause surface scaling and pitting in cold climates. Requires sealing.
- •Staining Issues: Oil, grease, and rust stains penetrate surface. Difficult to remove without acid washing.
- •Limited DIY: Requires skill, proper tools, and helpers. Small windows for finishing before setting.
💡 Best Use Cases:
- • Budget-conscious patios and walkways
- • Garage floors and workshop areas
- • Shed pads and equipment bases
- • Areas needing perfectly smooth surface
- • Utility areas where aesthetics less important
🛣️
Asphalt (Hot Mix)
Flexible paving material ideal for driveways and high-traffic areas
✓ Advantages
- •Lowest Initial Cost: $5-$12 per sq ft installed. Most economical choice for large driveways.
- •Quick Installation: Installed and usable in 1-3 days. Fast cure time compared to concrete.
- •Flexible Surface: Flexes with ground movement and temperature changes. Less prone to cracking than concrete.
- •Easy Repairs: Cracks can be sealed. Surface can be overlaid every 10-15 years to extend life.
- •Winter Friendly: Melts ice and snow faster than concrete or pavers due to dark color absorbing heat.
- •Salt Resistant: De-icing salts don't damage asphalt like they do concrete.
✗ Disadvantages
- •High Maintenance: Requires seal coating every 2-3 years ($0.15-$0.25 per sq ft). Skip sealing and life drops to 10-15 years.
- •Shorter Lifespan: 15-25 years with proper maintenance vs. 25-50+ for pavers or 20-30 for concrete.
- •Heat Sensitivity: Softens in extreme heat (90°F+). Can track into home. Tire marks and indentations possible.
- •Oil Damage: Gasoline, oil, and solvents dissolve asphalt binder. Permanent damage from spills.
- •Limited Aesthetics: Only black or dark gray color. No design flexibility or decorative options.
- •Professional Only: Requires specialized equipment and hot mix delivery. Not a DIY project.
💡 Best Use Cases:
- • Long driveways (>500 sq ft)
- • Parking areas and turnarounds
- • Cold climate regions (snow/ice)
- • Budget projects prioritizing function
- • Rural or agricultural settings
20-Year Total Cost of Ownership
Initial cost is only part of the equation. Consider maintenance, repairs, and replacement when comparing materials:
Pavers
$25/sq ft
- • Initial: $20/sq ft
- • Re-sanding (3×): $1/sq ft
- • Sealing (optional): $2/sq ft
- • Repairs: $2/sq ft
- Still in excellent condition at 20 years
Concrete
$22/sq ft
- • Initial: $12/sq ft
- • Sealing (6×): $3/sq ft
- • Crack repairs: $2/sq ft
- • Replacement needed: $15/sq ft
- Requires replacement by year 25
Asphalt
$19/sq ft
- • Initial: $7/sq ft
- • Seal coating (7×): $8/sq ft
- • Crack sealing: $2/sq ft
- • Overlay needed: $5/sq ft
- Overlay required by year 18
💰 Bottom Line: While pavers have the highest initial cost, they offer the lowest 20-year total cost of ownership when accounting for repairs, maintenance, and replacement. Pavers will still be in excellent condition after 20 years, while concrete and asphalt will need major work or replacement.
Which Material Should You Choose?
Choose Pavers If:
- ✓ You want the highest quality and longest lifespan
- ✓ Design aesthetics and curb appeal are important
- ✓ You're in freeze-thaw climate (prevents cracking)
- ✓ You value easy repairs without visible patches
- ✓ You can afford higher upfront investment
- ✓ Project is patio, walkway, pool deck, or high-end driveway
Choose Concrete If:
- ✓ Budget is primary concern
- ✓ You need perfectly smooth, flat surface
- ✓ Project is utility area (shed pad, workshop)
- ✓ Aesthetics are secondary to function
- ✓ You're okay with inevitable cracking
- ✓ You want faster installation than pavers
Choose Asphalt If:
- ✓ Project is driveway or parking area only
- ✓ You want lowest initial cost
- ✓ You're willing to seal coat every 2-3 years
- ✓ You're in cold climate with heavy snow
- ✓ Appearance doesn't matter (utility focus)
- ✓ You need large area paved (500+ sq ft)
Ready to Calculate Your Project?
Use our professional calculators to determine exactly how much material you'll need for your chosen surface.
Need more comparison tools? Visit MapEditor for additional resources.